Key Colony Real Estate Search

Newest Key Colony Homes and Condos for Sale

$875,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 608861 MLS
Welcome to your slice of paradise in Key Colony Beach! This immaculate east facing half-duplex offers the perfect blend of waterfront living and modern comfort. Boasting a larger 1,061 sq ft floorplan, this 2-bedroom, 2-bath gem is a testament to meticulous care and attention to detail, as it has been cherished by the same owner for an impressive 25 years. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by a spacious and thoughtfully designed layout, showcasing a complete down-to-the studs rehab in 2018. Every inch of this residence has been tastefully upgraded, creating a contemporary haven with a touch of coastal charm. The heart of the home is the fully-equipped kitchen, featuring a large island, granite countertops, custom built solid wood cabinets, and a convenient layout for both casual meals and entertaining. Step outside to discover your own private oasis, with 37.5 of dockage. This property offers quick access to the Atlantic Ocean or Gulf of Mexico via Vaca Cut, conveniently located at the end of the canal. The pride of ownership is evident in every corner of this residence. The current owner has maintained the property to the highest standards, with meticulous record-keeping of all improvements. From the beautifully landscaped grounds to carefully selected finishes, no detail has been overlooked. Additionally, enjoy the luxury of a 3-season room overlooking the waterway, offering an added 310 sq ft of living space. This versatile area provides the perfect setting to unwind, entertain, or simply bask in the beauty of your surroundings. With Key Colony at your doorstep, you'll have access to a vibrant walkable and bikeable community. This is a rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise with a rich history of care and investment. Don't miss your chance to experience the best of island living.

540 11th Street, Key Colony

$1,695,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 608481 MLS
Welcome to your slice of paradise in the heart of the Florida Keys! This meticulously updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath retreat embodies the epitome of coastal luxury and functionality, offering an array of features. Contemporary elegance as tile floors guide you through an open-concept living space that effortlessly combines style and comfort. The kitchen, adorned with stainless steel appliances, is a culinary haven, while the adjacent laundry room adds convenience to everyday living. The large primary suite is a sanctuary of tranquility, featuring a spacious layout, a luxurious walk-in shower, and a generously-sized walk-in closet. This private haven ensures the perfect escape. Extend your living space seamlessly as the open concept flows into the backyard oasis. A pristine salt water pool awaits, surrounded by a fenced-in yard that provides both privacy and security. The canal-front location offers a boat lift for easy watercraft storage, and the outdoor shower and fish cleaning stations add a touch of convenience to the coastal lifestyle. Boasting very easy ocean access via Vaca Cut. Currently serving as an active vacation rental, this residence offers a lucrative investment opportunity in the thriving vacation rental market. Beyond the property's boundaries, you'll find convenience in every direction. The house is strategically located close to a par 3 golf course, Marathon Airport, Sunset Park, as well as a variety of restaurants and grocery stores. This home offers the perfect base for experiencing the best of the Florida Keys lifestyle. Don't miss the chance to make this waterfront haven your own, call to schedule a showing!

150 10th Street, Key Colony

$3,699,000
608287 MLS
Welcome to Key Colony Beach, the ''Gem of the Florida Keys''. OPPORTUNITY to own a BRAND NEW CUSTOM HOME on a 8,555 square feet oversized waterfront corner lot near Sunset Park. OWNER FINANCING available!Offering includes a contemporary two-story CBS rooftop pool home breaking ground soon with an expected completion in 2024!The smooth concrete finish mixed with wood composite cladding imbues an elegant, modern architectural style. A true entertainers dream with chef's kitchen, open concept living and dining spaces, outdoor summer kitchen, complete with a rooftop infinity pool and terrace.Enter through the main level into the living room, kitchen with oversized island and dining room. Second level you will find one en-suite bedroom and two secondary bedrooms with jack & jill bath. The primary master bedroom suite is complete with a balcony, walk-in closet and terrace leading to the second story infinity pool. OPPORTUNITY to own new construction in beautiful Key Colony Beach within a short walk to popular Sunset Park, a public park and beach located less than a half of mile down the street.! Pre construction price and owner-builder reserves the right to adjust price as construction nears completion. Plans included for over 3712 sq. ft. of living space with ground level living area included and a roof top pool on the top floor living space. Four bedrooms and four full bathrooms and one half bath. Own one of the most beautiful locations in the Florida Keys. Located between Key Largo and Key West in the fabulous Florida Keys.

1000 W Ocean Drive, Key Colony

$1,299,000
608285 MLS
Welcome to Key Colony Beach, the ''Gem of the Florida Keys''. OPPORTUNITY for builders and investors to own 8,555 square feet of an oversized waterfront corner lot with OWNER FINANCING available! Price includes house plans, surveys and all associated documents relating to permits. The architectural style will be a smooth concrete finish mixed with wood composite cladding will imbue an elegant, modern and contemporary home.Plans include a true entertainers dream with chef's kitchen, open concept living and dining spaces, outdoor summer kitchen, complete with a rooftop infinity pool and terrace. Once you build this 'dream home' you'll enter through the main level into the living room, kitchen with oversized island and dining room. On the second level you will find one en-suite bedroom and two secondary bedrooms with jack & jill bath. The primary master bedroom suite is complete with a balcony, walk-in closet and terrace leading to the second story infinity pool. OPPORTUNITY to own a waterfront lot in beautiful Key Colony Beach within a short walk to popular Sunset Park, a public park and beach located less than a half of mile down the street.! Plans included for over 3712 sq. ft. of living space with ground level living area included and a roof top pool on the top floor living space. Four bedrooms and four full bathrooms and one half bath. Own one of the most beautiful locations in the Florida Keys. Located between Key Largo and Key West in the fabulous Florida Keys.

1000 W Ocean Drive, Key Colony

$1,799,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 608084 MLS
Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom canal front home that epitomizes the ideal waterfront lifestyle. The open floor plan of the interior immediately captures your attention, creating a sense of spaciousness and connectivity. The living area features large windows that showcase beautiful views of the canal. The heart of the home is the roomy kitchen, equipped with modern appliances, granite countertops, and a spacious bar perfect for casual meals or entertaining guests. For entertaining, a pool table is strategically placed in a dedicated space, adding an element of fun and recreation for residents and guests alike. Exit the living area to the patio, where a tiki hut awaits. This outdoor oasis is complete with an inviting bar, offering the perfect setting for enjoying refreshing beverages while taking in the relaxing views of the canal.The canal frontage is a boater's dream, featuring a 60-foot dock and a convenient boat lift. This allows for easy access to the open waters, making it a haven for water enthusiasts. Whether you prefer a leisurely boat ride or a day of fishing, the options are endless.This property is not only a wonderful private residence but also serves as an active vacation rental making it an excellent investment opportunity. Additionally, the fortunate residents enjoy membership to the Cabana Club, providing access to exclusive amenities and enhancing the overall experience of living in this tropical paradise.

240 5th Street, Key Colony

$2,225,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 608072 MLS
Welcome to your dream waterfront oasis in beautiful Key Colony Beach! This exquisite four-bedroom, four-bathroom half duplex boasts an open floor concept upstairs, creating a seamless flow from room to room and allowing for panoramic views of the canal waters.As you enter the home downstairs, you'll be greeted by a comfortable secondary living area with a mini frig overlooking the pool and canal. Two of the three ensuite bedrooms are located downstairs. Upstairs, the kitchen is perfect for both casual family meals and entertaining guests. The property features one en suite bedroom upstairs, a guest bedroom, and a full bathroom nearby. The primary bedroom is a true retreat with a jetted tub in the ensuite bathroom, providing a perfect spot for relaxation and indulgence. Outside, the tropical paradise continues with a heated pool, offering year-round enjoyment. The waterfront location includes a private dock for your boat, making exploring the nearby waters easy or heading out for a day of fishing. For the avid angler, a fishing closet and bait freezer are conveniently located near the dock. The one-car garage offers an extra refrigerator/freezer for added convenience. The garage also provides secure storage for your water toys and fishing gear. The property is equipped with 2-zone air conditioning and heating, ensuring comfort in every season. No need to worry about neighbors across the street; this location offers nice privacy while still being close to Key Colony Beach's amenities and attractions. Indulge in the laid-back luxury of this Key Colony Beach gem, where the waterfront lifestyle meets comfort and style. Your new home awaits as your primary home, or take advantage of existing vacation rental bookings.

661 8th Street, Key Colony

Start Your Search

Key Colony Homes for Sale

One of the hidden gems of the Florida Keys is the close-knit, seasonal community of Key Colony Beach. Because of its tight-knit community and abundance of charm, it was nicknamed years ago the “Gem of the Florida Keys.” This small island is accessible via a small bridge off Overseas Highway and a one-lane causeway. It has a fantastic location roughly one hundred miles south of Miami, on the oceanside of the Middle Keys, at Mile Marker 53. Key Colony is home to lovers of the outdoors, vacationers, and fishing enthusiasts. The winter population peaks at around four thousand, but usually, there are around seven hundred residents in Key Colony Beach. Phil Sadowski founded and developed the city in the early 1950s, and in 1957 Key Colony Beach was incorporated. It consists of two hundred and eighty-six acres and encompasses three miles of canals and roughly one thousand four hundred homes. 

Key Colony also boasts one of the Florida Keys’ few private white sand beaches where seven-day vacation rentals are allowed. Further adding to its desirability, Key Colony Beach offers a few boutique hotels, a deep-water marina, charter fishing fleets, several locally-owned shops, walkable home-town restaurants, and fantastic snorkeling opportunities at the reefs just offshore. Specific points of interest in Key Colony Beach include Sunset Park, Inch Beach, and restaurants like Sparky’s, Havana Jack’s, and Key Colony Inn.

Homes for sale in Key Colony Beach are as varied as the area’s amenities. There are beautiful oceanfront condos in Key Colony, as well as a variety of duplexes and single-family waterfront homes. Most Key Colony homes and Key Colony vacation rentals are built on deepwater canals or are oceanfront low-rise condos. Coco Plum deepwater boating channel and the Vaca Cut give Key Colony properties access to the Atlantic Ocean or the Gulf of Mexico. We would love to provide you with details about specific properties in Key Colony Beach, Florida, so please contact us today so we can assist with your Key Colony home or vacation rental search.

Our website features the best Key Colony real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in the Key Colony real estate market? Sign up for a Key Colony Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!