Key Colony Real Estate Search

Newest Key Colony Homes and Condos for Sale

$1,700,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 611761 MLS
Beautiful 3 bedroom, 3 bath home in Key Colony Beach. Meticulously maintained home. The top floor offers 2 bedrooms and 2 baths with an open kitchen and living room. The 1st floor has 1 bedroom, 1 bath with a sitting area facing the canal. Both living areas offer great views of the canal. This home comes furnished and has a good rental history.

411 5th Street, Key Colony
$2,000,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 611678 MLS
Full Duplex: Live in the gorgeous, NEW, lower level, which is above flood and all impact.Create exactly what you want on the BIG, upper level!Each level has 3 roomy bedrooms and 2 Full Bathroom.Great for the angler, boater and diver on a 100 ft wide, deep canal, plus only 5 minutes to the open Ocean and Gulf.Lower Level (490) - 1716 SF- Above Flood & All NEW in 2023 Upper Level (480) - 1778 SF - Make this yours!In Key Colony Beach, the heart of the Florida Keys. You can walk or bike the entire city to 3 restaurant, Marina, Pickleball, Golf, Tennis, Playgrounds, Horseshoes, Bocce Ball, Post Office and Sunset Park. Marathon Airport is 10 minutes away, Key West Int'l just over an hour, Miami Int'l approx 2 hrs and Ft Lauderdale only 2.5 hours....Here is your island getaway, vacation rental and retirement home in the Keys!

480 - 490 9th Street, Key Colony
$2,798,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 611435 MLS
Slide into paradise with this immaculate, renovated residence featuring an 80-foot composite dock, a substantial 30,000 lb. boat lift & direct Vaca Cut access for seamless Ocean & Bay excursions! The fenced backyard screams FUN with a large heated pool & unique Grotto with water slide, sure to entertain both kids & adults alike! Adjacent to the pool, a convenient full bath, large A/C storage room & expansive paver patio extending up to the circular driveway equipped with RV hookups. A panoramic view awaits from the wrap-around balcony with a sprawling screened porch connecting to 2 of the 3 bedrooms and the lavish open living spaces, protected by all impact windows & doors. With new electric, plumbing, water heater, and A/C, this meticulously redesigned home promises fun, low-maintenance living. Plus it's just .3 miles from beloved Sunset park, which offers lots more fun to be had!

541 12th Street, Key Colony
$3,970,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 611372 MLS
Amazing, wide open blue water views lure you onto the large balconies and patios of this custom build, 3600+ ft, concrete fortress. Enjoy entertaining friends and family with room to spare and views galore. Both the angler and boater will appreciate the great dockage for several vessels with IMMEDIATE access to the Ocean and a brief 6-8 minute cruise to Vaca Cut and the open Gulf. The 60 Ft Concrete Seawall has 2 lifts on the 30 ft Composite T-Dock. One 16k boat lift and 3k boat lift for your skiff or jetskis. Relaxing open patio for sunning and entertaining by the refreshing pool as well as an adjacent covered patio. Custom Built by Jeff Ryder, this home has quality finishes: 10 ft ceilings. crown molding, travertine flooring, Thermador and SubZero appliances, jetted tub, impact windows and doors and more... Great spacious, open floorplan with one Ensuite bedroom on the main living level. The 4th bedroom is currently used as, one of the three, Walk-In Closets. Equipted with an elevator to all levels. The 2 car garage is separate from the over 1800 sq ft ''Man Cave'' & great storage room on lower level. Lushly landscaped with paved, circular drive provides plenty of room for your vehicles, RV and boat trailer. It is apparent, this home has never been a rental and lightly lived in and waiting to become your piece of paradise!

160 1st Street, Key Colony
$850,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 611196 MLS
Charming Waterfront Property in Key Colony Beach a 2-bedroom, 2-bath half duplex that perfectly combines comfort, style, and a prime location. This beautiful waterfront property offers an ideal tropical retreat or a lucrative investment opportunity. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by a spacious interior featuring a sunroom that fills the space with natural light, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The modern kitchen boasts granite countertops and stainless steel appliances while having a view of your backyard. The open floor plan seamlessly connects the living and dining areas, making it perfect for entertaining guests or relaxing after a day on the water. The home features low-maintenance vinyl flooring throughout, ensuring both durability and a sleek aesthetic. Outside, you'll find 30 feet of dockage equipped with a boat lift, providing direct access to the water and just a quick 5-minute boat ride to the open ocean. Whether you're a fishing enthusiast or enjoy cruising the turquoise waters, this property is a boater's dream. Additional amenities include a covered carport, within walking distance to the Cabana Club (membership required), playgrounds, restaurants, Par 3 golf course and can fuel your boat and get bait at the Key Colony Beach Marina. Driving distance to Marathon Airport, grocery stores and other local amenities. The property's prior history as a successful vacation rental adds potential for it to become an income-producing investment. Don't miss out on this rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise in Key Colony Beach. Schedule your private tour today and experience waterfront living at its finest!

211 5th Street, Key Colony
$2,936,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 611073 MLS
Welcome to 200 14th Street, a luxurious, romantic hideaway for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Step inside to find a spacious and inviting Great Room with vaulted ceilings, perfect for relaxing with your better half after a long day. This home was custom built by the owners with the utmost attention to detail and craftsmanship in 2009. The travertine floors are ageless and the abundance of glass windows and sliders bring the beauty of the outdoors in. The kitchen is adorned with historic Chicago brick formations enveloping a state-of-the-art Viking stove. The wet bar with wine refrigerator, beverage refrigerator and ice maker make entertaining a breeze. The primary suite is a true oasis, complete with access to the pool and outdoor shower. The generous walk-in California custom closet will cater to all of your storage needs. The bathroom is all honed marble, including the walls, with rain shower, double vanities and a corner jacuzzi tub with privacy mirrored glass windows overlooking the tropical foliage outside. The guest bedrooms, located on the opposite end of the home, are spacious and well-appointed, providing a comfortable and luxurious retreat for your friends and family. Outside, the property truly shines. The tropical landscaping creates privacy and the free form pool with beach entry and waterfall features make this backyard oasis the perfect place to unwind. The flagstone pool deck is surrounded with artificial turf. There is plenty of room for your boat at the 50' dock with premium marine decking (Lumberock) and the 20,000 lb boat lift is a real bonus. Entertain your guests on the expansive 35' x 12' veranda with outdoor kitchen boasting a built-in grill, wet bar, built-in refuse cabinets and refrigerator drawers. There's also a gas fireplace and outdoor TV. Schedule a private showing of this spectacular home today and make your dreams of owning a home in the Florida Keys a reality.

200 14th Street, Key Colony
$4,195,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 611033 MLS
A rare opportunity, not to be missed! Located on prestigious Coury Drive, a hidden enclave in Key Colony Beach, you will find this beautiful home and neighboring lot. Nestled at the end of the canal, the home was specifically designed to take advantage of the breathtaking views straight up the long canal. A second or connected home can be built on the neighboring lot, which also has canal views.From the moment you arrive, you will appreciate the casual elegance of the home. Natural stone floors in a soft, neutral tone flow seamlessly throughout the house. High-end and thoughtful finishes are exquisitely appointed. The open floor plan with large glass doors provides an abundance of natural light, serene views, and easy indoor/outdoor living. The beautiful end-of-canal views grab your attention from the main living areas, primary bedroom and guest room, and the spacious wrap-around balconies. Perfect for your peaceful enjoyment or entertaining guests.The private backyard oasis offers another favorite spot for relaxation and fun with a large lap pool, hot tub, lanai and dock for your boat!Enjoy 3600 SF of well-appointed living space in addition to a generous 5000 SF of outdoor living space between the 2 open balconies and lanai. This does not include first-floor fully tiled enclosed area or garages.In 2007, the owner spared no expense building the home. Intentionally selecting the finest materials and workmanship and engineered the home for safety and beauty. For safety, the house comes with a concrete roof and walls, epoxy-coated rebar, impact glass, and an on-demand propane generator. For beauty, details include matched natural stone floors throughout, solid core doors, rounded walls, and more. See attachment for Property Highlights. The home has a good rental income history. Both Parcel IDs 00079872-006200 and ID 00079872-006100 to be sold together. Lot square footage is both parcels combined. Come take a look...you will be happy you did

1330 Coury Drive, Key Colony
$799,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 610982 MLS
Own your very own piece of Paradise! Stilted half duplex on boating canal in Key Colony Beach with dockage. Easy access to the Atlantic Ocean. Two bedrooms, two baths, 600 sq ft enclosed downstairs storage. Upstairs porch with westerly view overlooks the water. New metal roof (2018), HVAC unit, water heater, washer, dryer, and fridge, Lifetime dock (2015). Short walk to Sparky's and The Island Fish Co.Currently a rental with Cabana Club membership.

85 Coral Lane, Key Colony
$799,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 610951 MLS
Paradise awaits! Welcome to your 3 bedroom 2 bath dream home in Key Colony Beach. This stunning half duplex is perfectly situated on an oversized corner lot, offering both space and convenience. Located within walking distance to the Sunset Park, Cabana Club, restaurants, post office, golf, tennis and pickle ball courts. Security is always a must. We have our very own police department. This property promises an unbeatable Keys Lifestyle. As you pull up to the property, you'll immediately notice the ample parking space for multiple vehicles, making it ideal for family and guests. Additionally, the 1- car garage provides excellent storage space and protection for your vehicle. Step inside, and you'll be greeted by the beauty of vaulted ceilings that lend an airy and spacious feel to the entire home. The open concept design seamlessly connects the large kitchen, dining room, and living room, creating an inviting and harmonious living space. Nice private fenced in patio to relax, have your morning coffee, evening cocktails or great for a BBQ. This incredible property is offered turnkey and move-in ready, or as an investment vacation rental. Boat Owners - You have an opportunity to acquire a dry storage rack at The Boat House. The rack accommodates a 10' Beam and 32' Length boat. For an additional cost please inquire for more details. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own a slice of paradise in Key Colony Beach. Make this stunning half duplex your forever home or a perfect vacation getaway. Call today for a showing. Motivated sellers.

120 9th Street, Key Colony
$1,850,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 610862 MLS
Welcome to your coastal haven in Key Colony Beach--a paradise for those seeking a beautiful home and a relaxed lifestyle. This gem of a property with eastern exposure is offered fully furnished. Featuring 2-zone AC, marble pavers, and elegant finishes like Granite and marble counter and vanity tops. Boasting 9-foot ceilings, crown molding, a garage, concrete seawall, boat lift, and a step-down dock for a 37-foot boat, this residence seamlessly blends luxury with functionality. Enjoy the heated pool and the tropical ambiance in your backyard. Make this Key Colony Beach retreat your haven for a life of tranquility and leisure. Other half of this building (540 9th) can also be bought at the same price as 550 9th.

550 9th Street, Key Colony
$989,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 610782 MLS
Welcome to your dream home on Key Colony Beach! This stunning 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom house, built in 2020, showcases high-end finishes and water views from almost every room. The open-concept living and dining area is perfect for entertaining, offering sneak peek views of the ocean. The gourmet kitchen boasts top-of-the-line appliances and finishes, with easy access to the large back balcony, ideal for the avid griller. The master bedroom features an en suite bathroom complete with a walk-in shower and a spacious walk-in closet. The split floor plan offers 2 nice size bedrooms on the opposite side of the house, along with a full size laundry room and full bath. This home was built by the sellers and has never been rented, ensuring meticulous attention to detail and care featuring the highest standards with hurricane impact windows and doors, and a durable metal roof. This exceptional property offers the perfect combination of luxury, comfort, and location, making it an ideal choice for your next home. Easy to show and a must see!

180 15th Circle, Key Colony
$675,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 610499 MLS
BEAUTIFUL KEY COLONY BEACH HALF DUPLEX 2 BEDROOM -1 BATH BEING OFFERED TURNKEY! Deep Water Dockage 35 Ft Dock that can accommodate up to a 40 Plus Vessel! Permitted for Dock Extension along Seawall, that adds 5 Feet to back yard. Direct Ocean Access in less than 5 minutes via Bonefish Bay, No Fixed Bridges. Spectacular Open Water-Bonefish Bay Water Vistas! EXCELLENT RENTAL INCOME OPPORTUNITY-RENT WEEKLY. Key Colony Beach is its own City, it is very safe and peaceful, it has its own Police Department and Post Office. Newly Remolded Interior in 2018. All Hurricane Impact Windows, except the Glass Sliding Door. All New Electrical System with a 100 AMP Breaker Panel. New PVC Plumbing. New Rolled Roof in 2009. Renovated Kitchen, Granite Counter Tops, Stainless Steel Appliances. Full Size Standard Washer and Dryer. Newer 3 HVAC Ductless 12,000 BTU Mini-Split Air Conditioners-Heating and a 48,000 BTU Compressor! Tile Flooring. Parking for 2-3 Cars, can be 3 cars by parallel parking 1 car behind the other 2 cars. Amenities close by: Sunset Beach, Executive Par 3 Golf Course, Tennis Courts, Bike Paths, Marina with Charters and Boat Rental, Boat Ramp, and Boat Trailer Storage. Havana Jacks, and Cabana Club, offer Oceanside Restaurants and Bars. Also, Key Colony Inn Restaurant and Bar. NO HOA FEES IN KEY COLONY BEACH. SELLER FINANCING AVAILABLE. Paradise Awaits in Key Colony Beach.

5 Sadowski, Key Colony
$784,999
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 610308 MLS
Introducing ''Sunrise Serenity'' - Welcome to your turn-key east-facing waterfront sanctuary in the beautiful City of Key Colony Beach. Perfect for full-time residents or a high-end vacation rental potentially making $65k/y! This stunning 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom waterfront half duplex offers a rare blend of luxury, tranquility, and convenience. Impeccable craftsmanship and upscale finishes grace every corner of this home. The new '23 kitchen includes stainless steel appliances, Pompeii quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and gorgeous backsplash. Additional features include: 3 recently installed Mitsubishi mini splits, recently installed washer & dryer, updated bathrooms, and new accordion shutters protecting your glass sliders leading to your private outdoor paradise. Boaters will be delighted with the 30' dock leading to direct ocean access within minutes and ample room for a boat trailer along with 4+ spaces for vehicle parking. This gorgeous property offers not only luxury but also affordability with electricity averaging only $100/m and water costs at a mere $50/m. Not to mention the incredible assumable Flood Insurance Policy of $2,726/y. You can't beat it! The exterior of the property includes the same level of thoughtfulness as the interior. The self-sustaining landscaping in the front and back yard were designed to require almost no maintenance. The patio and sidewalk have custom pavers and privacy fencing. The sewer lines were replaced with desirable PVC allowing you to enjoy peace of mind and hassle-free living in this waterfront retreat. Don't miss the chance to experience the ultimate Key Colony Beach lifestyle - walk to restaurants, marina, pickleball, golf, tennis, playgrounds, post office, and an oceanfront park- schedule a showing today!

390 4th Street, Key Colony
$622,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 610266 MLS
Located deep in the heart of Key Colony Beach is this updated and stilted 2 bedroom 2 bath half duplex that is seconds away from beautiful beaches, a 9 hole golf course, restaurants and a marina. This CBS house was built in 1982 and has been recently upgraded with new appliances, countertops, tiles, floors, impact windows and more! This home also offers a spacious walk-in closet in the primary bedroom, a downstairs patio, laundry room and a garage. Use as your as your vacation getaway or utilize as an investment property with the 7 day rentals allowed. Highly motivated, bring your offers!

310 3rd Street, Key Colony
$810,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 610204 MLS
NEW IMPROVED PRICE! This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom half-duplex is located along a clean, wide canal with 30 feet of dock space, providing easy access to the direct ocean. The property features an updated kitchen and bathrooms, spacious bedrooms, and a lovely screened-in porch. It's being sold fully furnished, making it ready for immediate move-in. Tucked away at the end of the street, it offers privacy and a view of Shelter Bay. It's currently enrolled in a rental program. Key Colony is known as the 'GEM' of the Florida Keys!

520 4th Street, Key Colony
Start Your Search

Key Colony Homes for Sale

One of the hidden gems of the Florida Keys is the close-knit, seasonal community of Key Colony Beach. Because of its tight-knit community and abundance of charm, it was nicknamed years ago the “Gem of the Florida Keys.” This small island is accessible via a small bridge off Overseas Highway and a one-lane causeway. It has a fantastic location roughly one hundred miles south of Miami, on the oceanside of the Middle Keys, at Mile Marker 53. Key Colony is home to lovers of the outdoors, vacationers, and fishing enthusiasts. The winter population peaks at around four thousand, but usually, there are around seven hundred residents in Key Colony Beach. Phil Sadowski founded and developed the city in the early 1950s, and in 1957 Key Colony Beach was incorporated. It consists of two hundred and eighty-six acres and encompasses three miles of canals and roughly one thousand four hundred homes. 

Key Colony also boasts one of the Florida Keys’ few private white sand beaches where seven-day vacation rentals are allowed. Further adding to its desirability, Key Colony Beach offers a few boutique hotels, a deep-water marina, charter fishing fleets, several locally-owned shops, walkable home-town restaurants, and fantastic snorkeling opportunities at the reefs just offshore. Specific points of interest in Key Colony Beach include Sunset Park, Inch Beach, and restaurants like Sparky’s, Havana Jack’s, and Key Colony Inn.

Homes for sale in Key Colony Beach are as varied as the area’s amenities. There are beautiful oceanfront condos in Key Colony, as well as a variety of duplexes and single-family waterfront homes. Most Key Colony homes and Key Colony vacation rentals are built on deepwater canals or are oceanfront low-rise condos. Coco Plum deepwater boating channel and the Vaca Cut give Key Colony properties access to the Atlantic Ocean or the Gulf of Mexico. We would love to provide you with details about specific properties in Key Colony Beach, Florida, so please contact us today so we can assist with your Key Colony home or vacation rental search.

Our website features the best Key Colony real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in the Key Colony real estate market? Sign up for a Key Colony Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!